Part of the guide: Network Marketing Lead Generation
Every few months someone forwards me a comp plan and asks the same question: is this a pyramid scheme? They’re usually hoping I’ll say yes or no from the logo. I can’t. But there is an actual legal test, it’s been sitting in the record since 1975, and once you know it you can run it yourself on any plan in about twenty minutes.
I’ve been in and around this industry part-time since 2002. I’ve been paid well by it and I’ve watched it eat people. What follows isn’t my opinion about which companies are “good.” It’s the standard regulators actually use, plus the cases where they applied it, so you can stop arguing about vibes and start reading structure.
In this guide
The test: two elements, from Koscot
In 1975 the FTC went after Koscot Interplanetary and defined a pyramid scheme as a program where participants pay money to the company in return for (1) the right to sell a product and (2) the right to receive, in return for recruiting other participants, rewards which are unrelated to the sale of product to ultimate users. The FTC still cites this standard in its Business Guidance Concerning Multi-Level Marketing.
Read element two again, because that’s the whole thing. Not “does it have levels.” Not “is it steep.” Not “do the people at the top make more.” Every sales organization on earth is shaped like a triangle. The question is whether the money flowing up is generated by product moving to people who wanted the product, or by new participants buying their way in.
The Commission’s reasoning in Koscot is worth holding onto too: when recruitment rewards are lucrative enough, recruitment becomes an end in itself, which produces “insufficient sales for the insupportably large number of distributors whose recruitment the system encourages.” That’s not a moral complaint. It’s an arithmetic one. The structure manufactures more sellers than the market can absorb, and it does it on purpose, because the sellers are the customers.

“But we have a real product” is not a defense
This is the objection I hear most, and it has been tested in court.
BurnLounge sold online digital music stores. Real product, real digital goods, real bundles. The FTC sued anyway, and in 2014 the Ninth Circuit upheld the ruling against them. The court’s logic is the part to memorize: the product bundles existed, but the evidence showed participants bought them primarily to gain the opportunity — the right to earn recruitment rewards — not because they wanted a music store. Product presence didn’t cure the structure. Product demand was the question.
So the diagnostic isn’t “does a product exist.” It’s: would anyone outside the compensation plan buy this, at this price, if the opportunity vanished tomorrow? If your honest answer is no, the product is set dressing, and you’re looking at one of the clearest MLM red flags there is.
I’ve written before about what happens when a company confuses complexity with legitimacy — twelve product SKUs, four rank tracks, three bonus pools. Complexity is often how a plan hides the fact that nobody in the org has ever met a real customer.
Internal consumption: where most plans actually die
Vemma is the cleanest example. In 2015 the FTC moved to halt it as an alleged pyramid scheme; the agency noted the company took in more than $200 million annually in 2013 and 2014. Then look at what the 2016 settlement actually required going forward: Vemma was prohibited from paying an affiliate unless the majority of that affiliate’s revenue came from sales to real customers rather than to other distributors.
That remedy is a gift to anyone evaluating a plan, because it tells you exactly where the regulator draws the line. Not “some retail sales exist somewhere in the organization.” A majority of revenue, per affiliate, from people who are not in the plan.
AdvoCare is the same lesson at scale. The FTC sued in 2019 alleging the company operated an illegal pyramid scheme that pushed distributors to focus on recruiting rather than selling to customers. By 2022 the agency had returned more than $149 million to distributors who lost money. Read that number as what it is: not a fine paid by the company to the government, but money handed back to the field. The field was the customer base. That’s the tell.
The FTC’s consumer-facing page on multi-level marketing businesses and pyramid schemes makes the same point in plainer language, and it’s worth sending to a family member before they sign anything.
Own the audience your writing builds.
One honest post a day is the whole job. The network is built to bring your first readers, and search can bring more over time, and the list is yours to export, any time.
Start with the free show →The audit you can run this week
Take whatever plan is in front of you and answer these five. Write the answers down, because the act of writing them is what breaks the spell.
1. What do you earn on one retail sale to someone who will never join? Find the actual number. Then find what you earn when you sign a distributor who buys a starter pack. If the second dwarfs the first, the plan is telling you what it wants.
2. What percentage of company revenue comes from non-participants? Ask. If the company can’t produce it, or produces something vague about “customer volume” that counts distributor auto-ship, you have your answer. Legitimate operations track this because their lawyers make them.
3. Is there a required purchase to qualify for commissions? A monthly minimum you must buy to stay paid converts you from a seller into a customer of the plan.
4. Is there a buyback on unsold inventory when you quit? Amway’s buyback, its 70-percent rule, and its ten-customer rule were the guardrails that mattered in the 1979 decision that found it wasn’t a pyramid. Any company that quietly deletes those safeguards is deleting the exact features a regulator once treated as the difference.
5. Does the recruiting pitch sell a product or a position? “Ground floor,” “pre-launch,” “the spillover is coming” — those are position sales. Real value doesn’t expire at midnight.
Where this shows up now
The structure doesn’t die, it re-skins. I’ve watched the same playbook move into crypto and prediction markets, where the “product” is a token, a bot licence, or a trading education bundle nobody would buy without the referral tree attached. Token wrappers don’t change the Koscot analysis one inch. If the rewards flow from recruiting rather than from sales to ultimate users, the blockchain underneath is just a faster ledger for the same problem.
Part of why I stepped back from network marketing as a serious pursuit is that I got tired of teams where the distributor-to-customer ratio was five to one and everybody agreed not to mention it. The law isn’t the only reason to care about that ratio. It’s also the reason your check shrinks when recruiting slows, no matter how hard you worked.
One last thing
None of this makes you a lawyer, and nothing here is legal advice — a real determination depends on facts, jurisdiction, and how a plan operates in practice rather than on paper. But you don’t need a legal opinion to protect yourself. You need one number: what fraction of the money in your organization comes from people who are not in your organization.
Go get that number before you recruit one more person. If it’s low, no amount of belief work will fix it, because the problem isn’t your effort — it’s the direction the money flows.
If you’re trying to figure out what a structure looks like when the customer is actually a customer, start here.
Three posts a day. One email a day.
Everything I publish, in one short daily email. Real numbers, no hype, unsubscribe in one click.
Publish one post a day. Keep the list it builds.
Empower Network is a blogging network built to get your writing read. Your blog is live the day you set it up, the list is yours to export, and every paid product has a 30-day money-back guarantee. $25 a month or $197 a year.
Read the Blogging System letter →




What this piece is circling, in the Koscot ‘insufficient sales for the insupportably large number of distributors’ language, is close to what economists call a Ponzi-adjacent equilibrium — the mathematics of exponential recruitment against a finite population. It’s not a new observation; population-saturation arguments against MLM structures go back decades in the academic literature, though the legal test the piece describes is narrower and more useful than the general math argument, because it doesn’t require proving the whole population will eventually saturate. It only requires proving where today’s specific dollar came from.
Sorry, read Philip’s comment twice — is that different from ‘would people still buy it without the comp plan,’ or the same idea in bigger words? Genuinely can’t tell.
Steelmanning against Philip’s framing for a second — the strongest objection to the ‘insupportably large number of distributors’ argument is that it proves too much. Plenty of legitimate sales roles also can’t scale infinitely without cannibalizing the same customer base; that alone doesn’t make insurance sales or real estate brokerage a pyramid. The Koscot test the piece actually applies is narrower than the saturation argument, which is probably why it’s the one that holds up in court rather than the broader economic critique.
Ran the five-question audit on a company I looked at two years ago, before I knew any of this. Question 1 alone would have saved me three months — I never asked what I’d earn on a retail sale versus a signup, because nobody in that room ever said the word ‘signup’ out loud. Everything was ‘partnership.’ Different word, same bonus structure once I actually went and read the plan document myself.
In plain English, since half this piece is written for people who already went to law school: does the money come from someone who wanted the thing, or from someone who paid to get in? That’s the whole test. Everything after that first paragraph is worked examples of the same one question asked different ways.